It's a confusing day for a liberal, North American Jew like me. The Gaza pullout is essentially over, and it has gone far better than many predicted. The potential for confrontation looms larger in the four West Bank settlements to be evacuated later. I am thrilled that P.M. Sharon has made these moves, and saddened at the site of Jews being forcibly removed from their homes. I also wonder what this action will contribute to the overall progress toward peace. Hamas is spinning the pullout as a victory for violence. Will this incite more? I was also surprised to see that Sharon stayed well away from the scence of the pullout. Some words of conciliation might have lessened the tension. That being said, most Israelis seem to support the pullout, and there have been no mass demonstrations or riots.
Strategically and politically, disengagement from Gaza is easier than from either the Golan or the West Bank. The Golan Heights represent a critical buffer between Israeli citizens and the Syrians. Prior to 1967, the Syrian army would routinely shoot at farmers in the valley below the heights. This is no longer 1967, but Syria is still an enemy state and strong supporter of Hezbollah. Reliquishing the Golan Heights could provide a gateway for more terrorist activity in the north.
The West Bank is a political nightmare for the administration. Those who believe that it is critical that Judea and Samaria be populated by Jews in order to hasten the coming of the Messiah have a great deal of power. More importantly, pulling out of the West Bank means thinking about hoe
far to pull back.... and therefore the question of the unity of Jerusalem must be discussed. No Israeli government would dream of even discussing the division of Jerusalem.
For now, we can just keep hoping, and supporting positive moves made by whatever side.